44 Comments

  1. Brin

    Oh, this is super interesting. I know very little about this: is the new plugin something for absolutely all self-hosted sites? Or are there any disadvantages to using it? Or reasons some sites shouldn’t use it? Is the Tavern using it?

    Report

  2. Brian Gardner

    Curious to see how Google Analytics will be served on the AMP pages, because as I see it now, it’s not an option. If the overall idea is to serve faster pages, rank pages better who use it, how can we see the benefits without a way to track? Unless I’m missing something.

    Report

  3. Danny Brown

    This is a timely post. I’ve been poring over the AMP docs and (as a non-techy blogger-type) was trying to work out how I could use.

    Looks like the self-hosted plugin might be a nice option. Looking at the notes on the repo, though, there’s this bit:

    Note #2: this plugin only creates AMP content but does not automatically display it to your users when they visit from a mobile device. That is handled by AMP consumers such as Google Search. For more details, see the AMP Project FAQ.

    Does that mean users only see an AMP-powered post if coming in from search?

    Report

  4. mark k.

    AMP is a Big Win for the Open Web

    Totally not. google tries to force people into this kind of format to make better user experience on android devices by using probably false promises about “search engine ranking improvements”.

    If they cared about “open web” here they would have gone via the relevant standard bodies, and without the backing of facebook (which on mobile is a client of choice for many people to navigate the web) and apple (obvious why), the only thing “open” here is the marketing spin.

    Report

    • mac2net

      I just saw this:
      https://timkadlec.com/2016/02/a-standardized-alternative-to-amp/

      Looks like we have a debate on our hands. Move out of the way presidential candidates, we have web loading speed to discuss!

      Report

      • mark k.

        CPP sounds idiotic. If someone wants his page to load fast, why does he needs to ask the browser to enforce it on him?

        There is a reason why publishers do not want their users to have a second rate experience on mobile, either none google ads, or complex UI components, if they have wanted to degrade the mobile experience to make it faster, they could have done it easily. It is ridiculous that if my site serve a population of iphone 6 users in the US that I need to make a special version of it so it will load better on some cheap android in india.

        Report

    • Ryan Hellyer

      I’ve been thinking the same thing. This is an odd move by Google.

      Report

    • Piet

      I have done some reading up on the subject and I think it is nothing more and nothing less than a way for Google to compete with Facebook and Apple.
      AMP seems only useful to/for large news sites, and I think that the only reason many are getting so excited is, because it’s open source.

      Now I like to serve static content and software focusing on making it possible to serve WordPress statically is super interesting, I think. Not buying into this AMP thing though.

      Report

    • Anh Tran

      That makes sense. I think it’s better to create a standard for mobile content where AMP-similar rules are applied and when a website supports that, it will be displayed in the search results as “Optimized for mobiles”.

      Report

  5. Eugene

    Haha, google cares about web developers which will modernize client’s sites and make profit)

    Report

  6. Bowe Frankema

    I really hate everything about this.. Like others have said it’s simply another attempt by Google to force mobile websites to behave the way THEY want, with the threat of penalising those who don’t. Not only would it take a substantial amount of work to implement this in your projects, it’s also another thing to worry about. Nope. Nope. Nope

    Report

    • Johnny

      Someone needs to finally come up with a search engine that takes over google’s position (the same way google did take yahoo’s / AOL position).

      Report

  7. Fatima

    WHY does Google think site speed is the only determinant of a good mobile browsing experience? And why on Earth does it think it has the right to force publishers into adopting its own “optimization” standards? Not keen on the technical and/or “SEO” benefits of this, and not sold on the marketing spin.

    Report

    • Knut Sparhell

      Why do you say Google thinks speed is the only determinant of a good mobile browsing experience?

      In many areas of the world the available mobile networks offers only very low speed, or higher speed is very expensive for the average user. So lightweight mobile pages is very important.

      Report

      • Tony Haf

        Why change the entire world-wide-web’s algorithm while it makes more sense to upgrade the developing world’s equipment first?

        Report

        • Ed

          Ummm, you mean the developing world like the USA where LTE speeds rival those of India, where thirteen other countries have higher broadband speeds than the US?

          Point is, when most major news sites have “contributions” on the page from as many as a dozen different servers, something needs to break the logjam.

          Report

  8. Shachar

    All CSS must be inline and size-bound

    Thanks Google.

    Report

  9. Knut Sparhell

    The AMP project has to be seen in light of the initiatives by Facebook, Apple and Twitter to force all content into their own framework, instead of sharing links to content on the open web. If they succeed the open web will be killed.

    Making a new markup language, like amp, derived from html, and introduce stricter rules on what’s acceptable, is far from ideal.

    Earlier Google launched SPDY, but after HTTP/2 was standardized, they now abandon SPDY.

    There is no penalty by Google for not using AMP. Google has always had a strong focus on speed and unique content. Good mobile pages will be honoured as always.

    I have installed this plugin on a few of my sites and will start evaluating. See if I like it. See if there are benefits. The ordinary html pages are still available, even for mobile devices.

    BTW: I love the “Read mode” in Firefox, stripping down the page layout to something more readable.

    Why do we, the developers, create such bloated sites and pages, not focused on the content? And why does our clients demand such “nice”, advanced, bloated, visually stunning sites, instead of focusing on consuming the content? We do. I’m guilty as hell.

    AMP has made me think more about this, at least.

    Report

  10. Luke Cavanagh

    This post is of interest for how to add Google Analytics tracking to WP AMP posts.

    Report

  11. Luke Cavanagh
  12. javi

    john müller says IT IS NOT a ranking factor (currently)

    https://www.seroundtable.com/google-amp-not-a-ranking-signal-yet-21693.html

    Report

    • mark k.

      AMP are proper web pages and google said that speed is a factor in ranking, therefor I find it hard to imagine that they will demote AMP pages that are being linked to just because the “full version” is slower. They might not get any special treatment, but they don’t need to, just the speed factor will play for them.

      Report

  13. WG

    The plugin is an awesome start but isn’t as flexible and robust as it could be, especially for the non tech folks. We will be launching our own plugin very soon. Great initiative and I see a bright future for AMP. Can’t wait to see how it evolves. http://www.ampcoders.com

    Report

  14. wpmarc

    AMP is an interesting project. In my view it has one important drawback: You MUST load content for your webpage from the AMP cdn. This means your visitors are automatically tracked by a third party (even if you have no webfonts of google analytics). So this would be a no go for government, medical, privacy rights, and so on websites. It probably won’t matter for the majority of sites, as they already load js, webfonts and analytics from a cdn.

    Report

  15. Milton Ayala

    Thanks Sarah,

    I’m glad I stopped by today. Finally a little ray of hope for speed on mobile.

    Report

  16. Ed

    Interesting, but limiting. I installed the plugin and the AMP version of posts using an AJAX lookup plugin had it stripped out.

    Report

  17. Adnan

    I installed the plugin from 1 week ago, but does not appear in search results. I checked with developer tools and the code is valió.

    Example:

    URL : http://portalhoy.com/descargar-play-store-gratis/

    AMP URL: http://portalhoy.com/descargar-play-store-gratis/amp/

    The web is in google news, all going well but I do not see the AMP pages in search results. In the webmaster tools I have 1500 pages indexed with AMP and only 2 pages with errors.

    Someone knows what can i do?

    Thanks!!

    Adnan Faisal

    Report

  18. Mudasir Yasin

    Hi,

    I am also sharing my experience my about AMP, I install the AMP WordPress by Automattic on my blog Blogging World. After 4 days of Plugin Installation I see Error in my google webmaster tool that “Invalid attribute value” I do not know what is error about.

    I have a question is there is some syntax or other error created by this plugin caused this error or something else ? Is there is need to install any other plugin with AMP for best performance or not ?

    Effected URL showing in Google Webmaster tool:

    Report

  19. shahida

    hi i am also sharing my experience my about amp, l install the amp word -press by automattic on my blog blogging world. after 4days of plugin in- stallation i see Error in my google webmaster tool that “invalid attribute value ” i do not lnow what is error about.

    Report

  20. Mohammad Farooq

    I’m yet to update my Blog’s content to AMP as mst of the articles appear to be full of jargons which just bounces over my head.

    However with WP plugin, I’ll give it a shot and see if there’s a real value out of it for the blog.

    Also, will there be a built-in preview for AMP pages, or we have to do validation, like this article talks about: http://www.simplilearn.com/how-to-validate-accelerated-mobile-pages-quickly-via-google-article ?

    Report

  21. Edwin

    I’ve found amp plugin for magento stores by Plumrocket I think it really simplifies all the work with amp implementation. But still I have some doubts regarding amp technology.

    Report

Comments are closed.

%d bloggers like this: