10 Comments

  1. Ryan Hellyer

    I like the direction this is heading.

    Perhaps this would be better tackled by forcing the same page-type selector, but simply allowing users to choose from existing page templates there. Then you could use your custom meta box plugin of choice to control the meta boxes used for each template.

    I’ve also seen some custom themes which have forced users to select a page template before publish a page. That way you know the user has thought about which page type they’re publishing and not just accepting the defaults.

    Report

  2. Fredrik Forsmo

    @Ryan It’s an interesting idea, something I will think of later on.

    Report

  3. Ryan Hellyer

    I had a play around with this just now. Some observations:

    (1) This is not n00b friendly. If you aren’t happy burying your head in code, run away now.
    (2) The basic concept here is awesome. This can give a vastly simplified admin interface for handing things which can make for one hell of a messy UI for otherwise. I like it a lot.
    (3) Clean code. This makes me happy.
    (4) I can’t figure out how to make it load the correct template. Either documentation is missing, the plugin is broken, or I’m too dumb to figure it out. I didn’t put a lot of effort into working it out since I was just taking it for a spin to see how it works, but it definitely didn’t seem intuitive to me how it worked.
    (5) The CMB stuff still seems out of place. There are already very good plugins for WordPress which handle this sort of thing. I’m not see any reason to bake that functionality in here.
    (6) We need more plugins like this. I see too many custom sites which end up using a metric crap-ton of custom post-types, which results in a horridly complex interface and creates some weird URL setups, whereas a basic page is often all that is necessary. The only reason people often use custom post-types is because they need/want a way to differentiate them within the admin panel UI; this plugin works around this problem quite nicely.

    Report

    • Fredrik Forsmo

      Thanks for the feedback. Regarding the CMB I wanted a way to do this with just code and not via the admin ui that a lot of plugins does. I build Papi for me and my coworkers and released it as open source. So the CMB stuff will not be removed and Papi won’t be a programmatic interface against ACF or something other plugin.

      The idea for the plugin was to stop using CPT in a way that I think is wrong and the url as you say can’t be so good with CPT as you can’t place CPT below regular pages. In one project we solve this with a shortcut that a page fetched all post data from a CPT but this ins’t so great.

      But I hope that the idea around Papi can be a new way to think about pages in WordPress in bigger sites. It’s free to use as you wish or fork to build your own great plugin.

      Report

  4. Pablo Cruz

    I like this idea, a lot. I think it is necessary having something like this. I always say that CPT are okay if we need more than one item with a custom structure. When a CPT is set, you get the chance of adding as many items as you need. So if this is what you need, it is more than fine to use CPT.

    However, when you need a specific page with a custom structure, CPT is no longer a valid solution, since you would still have the chance of adding many items and it would break the original requeriment.

    I haven’t had the chance of taking a look at Papi, but I believe something like this is a necessary approach.

    Thanks a lot for you hard work and for contributing this big!

    Report

  5. Dave Chu

    I find this idea interesting and refreshing! I’ll have to think it over to dream up some good use cases. Having the possibility of a different URL structure sounds good.

    Also, bonus points for the name “Papi”, which is great in Spanish. ;)

    Report

  6. Carrie Lewis

    Lovin’ it!!

    Report

  7. Andreas Ek

    I’ve been using Papi for some month and in a couple of projects now and I’m impressed. Give it some time and you will miss the Page Type concept if you´r not using Papi in WordPress projects.
    Thanks, Fredrik! Your plugin is fantastic!

    Don’t forget to take a look at the testing process that comes with the source code to Papi!

    Report

Comments are closed.

%d bloggers like this: