14 Comments


  1. Wide net indexing gets a thumbs down. I searched for themes I knew were broken and they were listed. If they want that affiliate money then work for it by curating.

    Reply

  2. I have tried a few sites that “list all” and I believe those site are purely set up for the affiliate money. I understand that this is one way to earn some “easy cash”, but I don’t think it does the industry any good.

    Reply

    • Uhm, aren’t all businesses set up to earn money? Whether it’s affiliate money or easy money is pretty irrelevant, what’s relevant is does it provide people real value?

      Having said that, the current format falls a bit short because it doesn’t add a lot of information apart from some very broad categorization. It’s only the size that makes it interesting right now.

      If the affiliate model was working really well, there would be a very popular theme indexer site by now and we sure as hell have seen plenty of those and they all seem to go out of date.

      I’d really like to see a theme finder type site succeed though because finding a theme can be a pain.

      Reply

  3. Are you likely to visit a WordPress theme indexing site when shopping for your next theme?

    A big no.

    Reply

  4. There are already thousands and thousands of WordPress themes on net and the industry is growing widely. I believe they are looking into the affiliate commission from that site. Though it’s a nice idea, I wouldn’t think PressCastle will succeed in listing all the themes and will earn money from it.

    Reply

  5. I only work with the Genesis Framework, and I stick to their oficial themes, so I have no problem in finding themes. :)

    Having said this, I prefer a curated selection of themes with a good review of the code quality to another listings website with thousands of them.

    Reply
  6. Nemanja

    This could certainly prove to be very helpful, but it isn’t yet unfortunately…

    Reply

  7. I have created a small theme search engine for WordPress – http://www.qlue.co. It is a minimum viable product and needs further improvements. Your feedback and suggestions will be very much appreciated. Thanks :)

    Reply

  8. I very much appreciate the the mention here Sarah.

    Our goal at Press Castle is to provide the most up to date index. We know it’s not 100% yet which is why we’re in Beta and working through our processes to make it more and more accurate. We still have a ways to go, but we think we can have something really excellent in a few months.

    To those who think the site is unhelpful, has broken themes, etc. we take your feedback very seriously and would love for you to contact us with any specifics so that we can make adjustments.

    Thank you again Sarah and WP Tavern for featuring us, and thank you to everyone for your comments so far. We look forward to continuing to provide the most up to date index of themes on the net!

    Reply


  9. I would think that its usefulness and integrity will depend upon where the money comes from. If they end up taking money from specific sites to highlight their themes over another site’s themes, then so much for integrity and it becomes no more or or less useful than a timely google search.

    Reply

  10. Would I visit a theme indexing site? If it earns my confidence by reviewing the themes (both initially and after updates – especially if the theme changes ownership), publishing their review standards, and providing us reason to believe that they are not favoring a particular theme shop or otherwise showing bias, then yes. Of course, the use of affiliate links could be construed as bias, but reviews – and just finding the themes – takes time and commitment, so money does have to come from somewhere.

    Basically, if I can be assured that I (and, more importantly, novice users) will get better results than a “free WordPress themes” Google search, then it’s already worth something. But I do tend to take any index with a grain of salt and wonder where the loyalties lie.

    Reply

    • Hi Philip! The things you mentioned (theme reviews, public review standards, etc) are exactly what I’m working on at http://themefriendly.com, as mentioned toward the end of this article. I want it to be as useful as possible to potential theme buyers, so I’d love to hear any other suggestions you might have. Thanks!

      Reply

Leave a Reply