Some WordPress themes listed on the .org directory and indeed plugins can be blighted by premium options.

Personally I'd like a label denoting this as mentioned in this comment stream.

Also as a consumer information on the themes / plugins can be scant at times.

I'd be happy to write some physical reviews for the .org site of what you can expect and pitfalls etc.

Not everyone who uses WordPress is a developer or knows their coding onions.

I review premium themes as I need to develop revenue to buy more themes to review.

However thinking about it taking free themes and plugins and writing honest reviews might help individuals on whether a product is right for them or not.

I know I've gone a little off topic but the .Org directory is a go to place for many. If I can help (as I'm not a coder) with reviews and opinions from an end user point of view I'll do what I can.