In reply to Bastian.

Can you explain that argument?

I think wordpress.org moderators have the right to moderate their platform. WordPress.org is a community platform, not a market place. In my opinion having themes and plugins listed there isn’t a right or an entitlement, but a privilege and by doing so you comply to the .org rules.

However, these rules must be unambiguous clear to everyone that visits or uses .org and that clearly isn’t the case right now. Everyone (mods, developers and users) make their own assumptions on how the platform works, with all kinds of excesses as a result.