In reply to JDaniel.

Nobody used it. Literally, nobody used it at all. That system relied on users voting, and none of them did. They stopped a long time ago, after we added reviews. So, reviews it is now.

As to your example, 20 ppl saying they had problems out of over a million running it is not a representative sample. Nearly all plugins had "broken" simply because the only people who voted were those with issues.