@Andy McIlwain - I think it was the worst possible way to get a discussion started, but it worked. Unfortunately, he also received a bunch of links to the article. As long as that continues to happen, he'll continue with the practice. I feel somewhat stupid falling for the bait. However, there are some great posts that bring a level headed perspective to the table such as the one by Eric Mann http://eamann.com/biz/wordpress-falling-behind-still-leading/

I've actually read posts from both sides of the argument and they've all been much better at discussing the issues at hand versus the post that started the discussion.

Take a look at the history of posts from that author and you'll understand that posts like the one he published are great business opportunities, not wasted ones.