1. Jeff Chandler

    Well then, perhaps this paves the way for the options to be removed from core and put into a plugin.


    • Admin

      It would be interesting to know the most popular permalink structure(s).

      If a significant percentage of users use an alternative structure to the new default, like /%postname%/ or /%category%/%postname%/, making it a requirement for them to download a plugin to change that seems like a bad move.


    • Syed Balkhi

      Aside from the ability to change the permalink, don’t forget there is also another important use case of the Permalinks page.

      Flush rewrite rules to debug issues caused by plugins that return 404 for certain pages / new post types. Sometimes this happen because there is a conflict between two plugins.

      Usually an easy fix to that solution is: Go to your Permalinks page, don’t change anything, and simply click on Save Permalinks.

      This is huge help for beginners who don’t want to flush rewrite rules by placing a code in their functions.php file.


  2. antsanchez

    That may cause a fatal error in servers which don’t let the user administrate the .htaccess file by default..


  3. Hugh

    This is great – stoked this is finally happening. It would be nice, however, to have the option of your preferred permalink structure as part of the install process – my reason being that I never use %day% in my permalinks and almost always just use %postname%, so even though this sets pretty permalinks, I will always still go and edit them on any production site. That obviously has the downside of adding another step to the installation process though, so not sure what the best solution is there.


    • Jeff Chandler

      In my experience, permalinks are one of those settings in WordPress that are set and forget. Once you have the ones you like, you never touch them again unless it’s part of the troubleshooting process. That’s an interesting idea to present the options on install and I don’t think it would be hard to explain what they are on the screen.

      This move is aligned with the decisions over options development philosophy but as you illustrate, WordPress doesn’t make the right decision for you.


    • John Blackbourn

      This change is just about providing a better default for the majority of users. The change has a net benefit to inexperienced and first time users, and effectively makes no difference to those users who would change their permalink structure anyway.


    • jawittdesigns

      I agree with Huge.

      When I read the title of this article I just knew that they would default it to a type that I never use. In 99.9% of the sites I’ve made and worked on, I only ever used just %postname%.

      I think it comes to the core team still treating WP as a blog instead of a CMS. I’d wish they’d get over that already.


  4. Benjamin Intal

    This is great. And yes, this is really one of the first things we do in new WordPress sites.


  5. donnafontenot

    Agree with Hugh. Choice of format on install would be ideal. But it’s nice to see them do something rather than nothing on this little issue.


  6. dhgilmore

    How would this affect multisite installations already running? My customer requires ugly permalinks, and we have new sites created almost daily.


  7. Brin Wilson

    I wonder why the newly elected default setting is the one with the date in it? …can’t help thinking that including the date is a bad move for the majority of users and it would be better to just go with ‘postname’… :(


  8. Brin Wilson

    Forgot to mention: “The new function is the result of a ticket that was originally opened seven years ago.” – so it didn’t take long then?! Lol


  9. BobWP

    Yeah, I’m with some others, I’d like to see this without the date.


  10. Cavalary

    I for one just use the number id and sure hope I won’t be forced to change it in any way…

    And as a rule, always options, no decisions forced on users. Why I dread updating pretty much anything for the past several years and put it off as much as I can or even avoid it altogether, with this mindset being so common now.


  11. Keith Davis

    Sounds good to me since it’s one of the first things that I change on all new installs.

    And then as Jeff suggests “In my experience, permalinks are one of those settings in WordPress that are set and forget.”


  12. Rick Wiley

    Can’t say I oppose such a feature. I rarely have a client that wants permalinks outside of /%category/%postname%/


  13. Miroslav Glavic

    /%category%/%post% <— I like it that way, THAT is PRETTY for me. If WordPress changes this to some other PRETTY then I will be PRETTY upset


    • Drew Jaynes

      This would only affect new installs.


    • Scarecrow

      I know they claim not to use %category% but I have used it like this. note post_id thrown in to make sure no identical links that may conflict.


      I don’t see a problem with this; however, unless you want to run buddypress or some other feature that requires permalinks, url rewrites, and caching, I would just leave the default on a small traffic site. No need in changing the default without good reason whatever that default may be.


  14. Greg Wallace

    +1 for just using %postname%. The proposed change will be so much better than the old SEO unfriendly permalink setup though.


  15. Deborah Edwards-Onoro

    Glad to see the change, but my vote is for %postname%.


  16. Enstine Muki

    For the past 2 years, I have not read a blog post with the ugly link so i was beginning to wonder why in recent updates, this point is not addressed.

    good to know 4.1 has it sorted out ;)


  17. Nick Haskins

    We run a multisite setup and ours default to /postname/ so I’m agreeing with the others in that , if it’s between postdate and postname, I’d much rather prefer postname


  18. Kyle Alm

    Why pick the ugliest pretty permalink as default? /


  19. Michael Beil

    The discussion continues on `/%postname%/` and `/%year%/%monthnum%/%day%/%postname%/` over on trac: https://core.trac.wordpress.org/ticket/6481#comment:87

    I would personally prefer `/%postname%/`.


  20. Cory Church

    ’bout time.


  21. CLCShare Cloud (@CLCShareCloud)

    Perhaps the default is being set to be efficient with /%year%/%monthnum%/%day%/%postname%/ for cache plugins such as WP Super Cache that WP offers right next to JetPack as a top 5 add-on at installation. WP Super Cache can be set to ignore certain pages; “Add here strings (not a filename) that forces a page not to be cached. For example, if your URLs include year and you dont want to cache last year posts, it’s enough to specify the year, i.e. ’/2004/’. WP-Cache will search if that string is part of the URI and if so, it will not cache that page…” i.e. wp-.*\.php or index\.php


  22. DeanEthridge

    Thanks for the post! I had a problem with my permailinks and this article was helpful. I appreciate you putting this out here for us


Comments are closed.

%d bloggers like this: