In reply to Jeffrey.

You should first try to evaluate a theme by your needs and how it fulfills them. If it doesn't sit well with the value you see in it, then surely it is not a theme for you. I don't think one can have definitive conclusions. On some projects, it may be too much, on others maybe no so much.

For too long people have assessed themes only on their demo and the "promises" some authors chose to make because every theme was priced the same. Now you need to take into account a larger picture that includes the visual aspects, but should also make support and updates factors in their purchase decision.

I think this approach allows mutual respect between client and theme author to flourish.