In reply to Jim Walker.

True: the ethical & legal often get short shrift on the net.

But, the net can also do an impressive 'judge, jury & executioner'.

Especially when trying to get established with a strong self-identifying (competitive) net community - like WordPress.

Once members with a meaningful voice decide they don't like an activity or service - they don't talk to lawyers or write essays on ethics - they just come around broadside and start pounding away.

I don't think that is necessary or called-for, certainly not at this stage. The Theme-Check site is a good idea, basically, and it could be a upgrade for WordPress generally, and for themes in particular. Themes need more attention; more acclaim ... plugins are kinda hoggin' the glory these days.

I figure a shot or two across the bow is plenty-good for now, just to clarify proprieties.