@Robbie - Who cares? Again, you need to know the history. Both between Matt and Thesis as well as Genesis and Thesis factoring in just who Matt Cutts is.

IF Matt did ask Matt Cutts to switch from Thesis to another theme, he did so for vindictive reasons that will have a direct negative impact on someone else's business while providing a positive impact on that person's competitor.

Thesis can no longer promote the fact that Matt Cutts, Google's SEO demigod, uses Thesis. StudioPress can now promote the fact that Matt Cutts, Google's SEO demigod, uses Genesis.

You seriously see nothing wrong with that if this is indeed what happened?

So i'm assuming you'd see nothing wrong if I approached every site running a Gravity Forms competitor and told them if they switch to Gravity Forms i'll not only give it to them for free but i'll also handle the migration so they don't even need to do anything?

I want users to use Gravity Forms because they want to use it because it's a good product. I want them to make the decision. I don't want them to use it because I talked them into switching from a competitor, provided it for free and handled the setup and migration for them.

I certainly see something wrong with this kind of business tactic, especially when it negatively impacts someone else's business for no other reason that being vindictive. It's something I would never do to a Gravity Forms competitor.