In reply to Dev.

It is difficult to review a theme when you have access only to a Live Demo, with no access to the back-end and set up process.

As such, you either have to ask developers for a free copy (rarely given), or you have to work it out just from the source code of the demo. Of course you can analyze performance and quality of CSS code, but that is not always sufficient.

An honest, public reviewer of themes, with no direct interest as an affiliate?
One man can't review more than 2 themes per work day.
Would developers submit their theme for review, when previous themes got 6/10 or "this theme is sh!t" marks? :)