25 Comments


  1. I would draw the conclusion that the new small-scale plugin workflow in WP core was a direct result of the post formats mess, so that’s a positive.

    Reply

  2. Some really good points there Jeff, and will have to read Grace’s post as well. I think before anyone, especially the casual user or blogger even tries them, we will need to educate them more and more on it. Even then, I’m not sure how many will get very excited :).

    I remember at a local WordPress meetup when myself and someone else was doing a presentation on what we might expect to see in 3.7, and asked how people were more casual users and bloggers, not designers and devs, to raise their hands, then asked for any of them that understood post formats to keep their hands up, every single one went down. Even an overall poll with everyone showed very few people who would use them.

    Myself, well, I never use them at all. What can I say?

    Reply

    1. Spot on Bob. The use case scenario is unclear and poorly defined (see my longer comment below). If I remember correctly there was once a conversation about creating custom post templates and post formats suddenly took over for that. What people seem to want is custom post templates. When post formats were first introduced they looked like post templates but were not. When the post formats UI was introduced it looked even more like post templates but still was not.

      Reply

  3. It looked like a knee jerk reaction to the popularity of Tumblr which was built around this concept of these types of formats. But WordPress isn’t Tumblr so i’m not surprised it’s not a very popular feature. Supply and demand. Theme development is driven by demand and IF there was a large demand for themes that used Post Formats then we’d see a lot of themes that use them. But we don’t.

    Reply

    1. Could part of it also be that many theme devs take cues from what core is doing? If and until core sets a standardized way of dealing with formats, I think theme devs will be holding off. No sense in picking their own path and sinking the dev resources if the path they choose isn’t the path core chooses.

      Reply

  4. I really like the post format feature since it was introduced and some personal projects (themes) I’ve started use post formats as one of the main feature. I find them useful not only for bloggers, but also for magazines for different topics as well.

    Reply

  5. Sorry, my dyslexia prevents me from reading the original article in full. However I have thought about this topic and experimented with Post Formats at length and I have my own theories as to why they are not used much and why they are not a wise thing to pursue. It all boils down to one basic point: The use case scenario is not one that people are asking for.

    Let’s take the Image and Video post formats as an example. The use case scenario here is clear: You create a post that only contains an image or a video. Nothing else. This is not a common thing to do nor is it recommended. I’m sure some will say this is not a correct interpretation. I beg to differ and I can show you why:

    Create a couple of video posts containing a videos and content and apply the Video post format. Then activate the Twenty Fourteen theme, add the Post Formats widget to your sidebar, and point it to the Video post format. Finally visit a single post in your site and look at your sidebar. What you’ll see is the entire post displayed including video and text and whatever else you put in there.

    At first I thought this was a mistake, but when I look at the code for other post format themes it is the same. Clearly the idea here is that people want to just post an image or a video and nothing else. While this may be how some people do it (especially people who come from Tumblr or similar services), it is not the standard method of posting content in WordPress.

    To put it another way, the Post Formats feature is for a small subset of WordPress users.

    Personally I think Post Formats should be removed from core and added as an optional plugin. What’s needed in the core is support for post templates equivalent to page templates. Post formats is something else and imho something that will never catch on.

    Reply
    1. eliza

      You may have a point regarding post formats being for a small subset of WordPress users. I’m a recent tumblr transplant and tried out dozens of WordPress themes until I finally settled on one that supports post formats (there are actually a few that I like that support post formats)… just because it made the most sense for my type of content – images, audio, quotes, etc. I have no interest in the traditional blog structure at this point. Not sure how many others are like me, but I do appreciate the development of themes with post formats.

      Reply

  6. We use them quite often on SweetwaterNOW.com. Very handy especially in a pressing time constraint environment.

    Reply

  7. I think one of the biggest drawbacks of developing for them (and therefore using them) in the first place is that most themes don’t develop for them.

    The chicken and the egg…

    As long as that is the case and therefore theme switching is potentially destroying one’s site, I think nothing much will happen with Post Formats, I know I don’t develop for them and actually remove them from sites I develop for clients.

    Reply

  8. I like the idea of post formats, because it somewhat meshes with my blogging pattern. While I also write longform posts, I also want to post just a link with commentary, or just an image, or just a gallery, or just a quote… The formats capability helps to “shape” the content appropriate to the selected format. Yes it’s a little more work in the templates, but I think it adds some…appeal to posts if nicely implemented.

    The obvious downside of course is that not all themes support them, or all of them, or consistently, even. I’ve been using the Crowd Favorite plugin (originally by Alex King) for some time because it adds in functionality that persists across themes. So that metadata can be theme-agnostic.

    Reply

  9. For most cases where I’ve actually been bothered to use them I haven’t wanted them all. So nearly always need to unclutter the interface by disabling some. But for most of the time they just get in the way and are an annoyance.

    +1 having post templates is a far better option.

    Reply
  10. pixeldesu

    I use them quite often, for special showcasing posts where the main-content are videos or music. With the post formats I also can keep those posts sorted well from the others.

    Reply

  11. I agree that it’s like Beta v VHS. (assuming you’re old enough to understand that reference). Until a standard is reached, given that people like to “change” on a whim, it falls into the same category as shortcodes – they should be a contemplated extra in order to avoid the “lock-in”.

    Reply

  12. Time to show my ignorance.
    Are post formats the same as custom post types?

    I did check it out over on WordPress.org but I’m non the wiser.

    Reply

    1. Hardly ignorant Keith, but a sure sign of why they’ve gained no ground – few beyond the world of developers are really aware of them and few beside developers have bothered to promote them. They’re templates for the except view of your posts. Have a look at digwp.com for an example. They designed the format to using a chain for short posts that only need to show a link. Or at least that’s as close a description as I can give since I’m not one of those developer types :)

      Reply
  13. QOOLOS

    The underlying problem in my opinion is that changes to WordPress are not very clear. Yes, you can lookup a changelog, but apart from a nice story about some jazz artist and a couple of screenshots of the new media manager, there isn’t much to be found about this snazzy new feature (post formats, that is). Also whenever a new feature is added to WP core, the lazy documentation team of WP is ALWAYS late with updating the documentation regarding new functions, etc. They drop an entire new theme every year, but they fail to properly document important changes well in time.

    If they would’ve promoted post formats better, maybe more developers would use it.

    Reply

    1. … the lazy documentation team of WP is ALWAYS late with updating the documentation regarding new functions, etc.

      Whoa whoa whoa.

      Funny that you have zero qualms labeling the entire docs team lazy while simultaneously not offering to help in any way. I think I’d be fairly accurate in guessing that you actually have no idea what you’re talking about.

      They drop an entire new theme every year, but they fail to properly document important changes well in time.

      Yeah. You’re either trolling or just a jerk.

      Reply

    2. @QOOLOS

      Thank you very much for your kind words to all of us that contribute to WordPress volunteer somehow. I’ll take your note and see to get involved more and to concentrate on the Post formats documentation.

      I’m just curious, what’s your real implication in the WordPress community, with the exception of your “kind words” to us?

      Reply

  14. Hi Jeff! Just chiming in here to say thank you for the mention. I’m glad the article helped. I do really hope Post Formats can take off in the WordPress community, in one form or another. They’re obviously not going to be for everyone, but I think they are under utilized as a feature in general and lost their lime light a little too soon. I hope we can start giving them more of a chance. I think it’s mainly our clients, or content producers, that will notice their difference.

    The development debate is one thing, but I think we should think of how the users will be able to make use of them. The motive is more on the side of being able to spread content easier and faster, rather than to debate about how they should be developed (in my opinion anyway!). I think that’s what most of us here are saying too. I don’t care how they are made (plugin or not, as you identified), but I do see their potential to help bloggers, which is in line with what WordPress is all about anyway.

    Reply

Leave a Reply